How to Measure the Success of a School Garden Program

How to Measure the Success of a School Garden Program

Measure a school garden program by choosing a few outcomes before you plant, tracking them with simple tools such as short student surveys and a garden-use log, and reviewing the results on a set schedule. Start with outcomes that fit your goals, like student engagement, how often teachers use the garden, and whether the garden is still thriving a year or more from now.

Start with outcomes, not harvest counts

Pounds of tomatoes are easy to count, but they say little about whether students are learning. A better starting point is a list of outcomes that school garden professionals agree matter. University of Florida Extension researchers surveyed a panel of 74 Florida school garden stakeholders, including people from state agencies, nonprofits, universities, and school systems, and asked them to agree on which outcomes belong in an evaluation. The result is a menu of short-, medium-, and long-term outcomes you can pick from.

You do not need to measure everything on that list. The authors suggest choosing outcomes based on local needs and turning them into measurable objectives within a simple logic model, which is a diagram connecting your garden's inputs, activities, participants, and outcomes.

What to measure in the short, medium, and long term

The expert panel sorted outcomes by how long they take to show up. That timing helps you decide what to track in your first semester and what to save for a year-end or multi-year review.

Short term: knowledge, attitudes, and skills

  • Students' knowledge of where food comes from
  • Life skills such as teamwork, responsibility, focus, and patience
  • Teachers' skills for connecting garden work to several subjects

Medium term: changes in behavior

  • Students pay more attention and participate more in lessons
  • Students spend more time outdoors engaging with nature
  • Teachers develop and use garden-based lessons that connect to state standards
  • Adults and students create a shared plan for managing the garden

Long term: lasting change

  • A garden that is sustained for multiple years
  • A better outdoor school environment
  • More partnerships that support school gardens

Sustainability deserves extra attention, because a garden that stops being used cannot produce any of the other outcomes. If that worries you, read why school gardens stall in the first semester.

Simple tools that work without a research team

Good evaluation tools can be short. These are the ones that show up in published school garden programs.

  • Surveys. A multi-state Extension effort, the People's Garden School Pilot Project, used surveys at school and at home along with garden records of activities and production. A 2017 master's thesis reviewing eight published school garden studies found that all of them used surveys in some way. Keep yours to a handful of questions and ask the same ones before and after.
  • A garden-use log. This is a clipboard or shared sheet where each class records the date, grade, and what they did. The FONA school garden support program report ties each evaluation question to a performance measure, including goals such as increasing how many school staff use the garden. A log is how you count that.
  • A garden condition checklist. The UC Davis School Garden Assessment Tool is designed to identify and track areas of improvement in school garden programming. It asks about things like whether the garden has a coordinator who is part of the school and a committee that supports it.
  • Stories and quotes. An evaluation of the Stephanie Alexander Kitchen Garden program paired qualitative measures, which capture changes in school culture and the experiences of children and teachers, with quantitative measures at baseline and one year later. Collect a few student and teacher quotes each term to sit beside your numbers.

A simple scorecard you can run this year

If you want a starting point, this five-step scorecard fits on one page.

  1. Pick three outcomes: one short-term, one medium-term, and one long-term.
  2. Write one measure for each, such as a before-and-after survey question, a count from your garden-use log, or a yes or no on whether the garden has a team and a written plan.
  3. Record a baseline in the first month, before students start planting.
  4. Review every term with teachers and garden volunteers, and ask what the numbers do not capture.
  5. Share a one-page summary with your principal, your PTA, and any funder.

Match your measures to your audience

A principal may care most about instructional time and student engagement. A PTA may want to see participation and family involvement. A funder will have its own reporting requirements, so ask what they want counted before you design your tools. If you are still looking for funding, our guide to funding a school garden with no budget walks through seven routes, and the results you track now will give your next application real evidence to draw on.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Measuring too much. Three well-chosen measures beat fifteen that nobody has time to collect.
  • Waiting until the end. Without a baseline, you cannot show change.
  • Counting only the harvest. Pounds of produce do not show learning or engagement.
  • Skipping the planning step. Goals set at the start make measuring simple. Our guide to starting a school garden is a good place to set them.

Frequently asked questions

How soon will we see results?

Short-term outcomes show up first. The UF/IFAS panel defined short-term outcomes as changes in knowledge, attitudes, skills, and aspirations, medium-term outcomes as changes in behavior, and long-term outcomes as social, economic, and environmental change. Track short-term outcomes in your first semester and save the long-term ones for an annual review.

Do we need a formal research study?

No. The UF/IFAS paper presents its outcomes as a menu to select from based on local needs, not a checklist to complete. Most school programs can start with a few simple measures tied to their own goals.

What if teachers have no time to collect data?

Build collection into routines teachers already have. A garden-use log takes seconds at the end of a class, and a short survey can run at the start and end of the year. Name one garden lead to gather everything in one place.

Next steps

Measuring is easier when you teach from a set curriculum, because every lesson gives you something concrete to track. The school raised garden bed kit with a full-year NGSS curriculum includes a 32-week NGSS-aligned curriculum with worksheets and vocabulary, plus grade-by-grade standards alignment documentation, so teachers and funders can see what students are expected to learn.

Ready to start your own school garden? We'll send a free, itemized quote you can drop straight into a grant or purchase order.

→ Contact us now!

→ Need grant help? We are here to assist!

Back to blog